The effect of a simulation training package on skill acquisition for duplex arterial stenosis detection

In vascular surgery, duplex ultrasonography is a valuable diagnostic tool in patients with peripheral vascular disease, and there is increasing demand for vascular surgeons to be able to perform duplex scanning. This study evaluates the role of a novel simulation training package on vascular ultrasound (US) skill acquisition.

A total of 19 novices measured predefined stenosis in a simulated pulsatile vessel using both peak systolic velocity ratio (PSVR) and diameter reduction (DR) methods before and after a short period of training using a simulated training package. The training package consisted of a simulated pulsatile vessel phantom, a set of instructional videos, duplex ultrasound objective structured assessment of technical skills (DUOSATS) tool, and a portable US scanner. Quantitative metrics (procedure time, percentage error using PSVR and DR methods, DUOSAT scores, and global rating scores) before and after training were compared.

Subjects spent a median time of 144 mins (IQR: 60-195) training using the simulation package. Subjects exhibited statistically significant improvements when comparing pretraining and posttraining DUOSAT scores (pretraining = 17 [16-19.3] vs posttraining = 30 [27.8-31.8]; p < 0.01), global rating score (pretraining = 1 [1-2] vs posttraining = 4 [3.8-4]; p < 0.01), percentage error using both the DR (pretraining = 12.6% [9-29.6] vs posttraining = 10.3% [8.9-11.1]; p = 0.03) and PSVR (pretraining = 60% [40-60] vs posttraining = 20% [6.7-20]; p < 0.01) methods.

In this study, subjects with no previous practical US experience developed the ability to both acquire and interpret arterial duplex images in a pulsatile simulated phantom following a short period of goal direct training using a simulation training package. A simulation training package may be a valuable tool for integration into a vascular training program. However, further work is needed to explore whether these newly attained skills are translated into clinical assessment.