Comparison of SIRT and SQS for Regularized Weighted Least Squares Image Reconstruction

Tomographic image reconstruction is often formulated as a regularized weighted least squares (RWLS) problem optimized by iterative algorithms that are either inherently algebraic or derived from a statistical point of view. This paper compares a modified version of SIRT (Simultaneous Iterative Reconstruction Technique), which is of the former type, with a version of SQS (Separable Quadratic Surrogates), which is of the latter type. We show that the two algorithms minimize the same criterion function using similar forms of preconditioned gradient descent. We present near-optimal relaxation for both based on eigenvalue bounds and include a heuristic extension for use with ordered subsets. We provide empirical evidence that SIRT and SQS converge at the same rate for all intents and purposes. For context, we compare their performance with an implementation of preconditioned conjugate gradient. The illustrative application is X-ray CT of luggage for aviation security.