Asymmetric Hybridization in Cattails (Typha spp.) and Its Implications for the Evolutionary Maintenance of Native...

Cattails (Typha spp.) have become an increasingly dominant component of wetlands in eastern North America and this dominance is largely attributable to the high frequency of Typha × glauca, the hybrid of native Typha latifolia and putatively introduced Typha angustifolia. Hybridization in this group is asymmetric, with T. angustifolia nearly always the maternal parent of F1 hybrids. However, the magnitude of hybrid infertility and whether mating asymmetries extend to the formation of advanced-generation hybrids have not been examined. We used hand-crosses to measure seed set and germination success. We found that mating asymmetries extend to the formation of back-crosses, with ~0 seeds set when T. latifolia was pollinated by hybrid cattails. Seed set was unaffected by pollen source for T. × glauca or T. angustifolia. However, seed production by T. angustifolia was consistently high while that of T. × glauca was variable and when pollinated by other T. × glauca more than 75% lower than for any other intraspecific cross indicating reduced hybrid fertility. We used these results to parameterize a model of hybrid zone evolution in which mating patterns and fertility were governed by interactions between alleles at nuclear and cytoplasmic loci. The model revealed that asymmetric mating and reduced hybrid fertility should favor the maintenance of T. latifolia over T. angustifolia compared to null expectations. However, the model also indicated restrictive conditions for the long-term maintenance of T. latifolia within populations, indicating that asymmetric mating might only stall rather than prevent the displacement of native cattails by hybrids.