Diaphragmatic thickness ratio (inspiratory/expiratory) as a diagnostic method of diaphragmatic palsy associated with...

Diaphragmatic paralysis is a side-effect associated with interscalene block. Thickness index of the diaphragm muscle (inspiratory thickness/expiratory thickness) obtained by ultrasound has recently been introduced in clinical practice for diagnosis of diaphragm muscle atrophy. Our objective was to evaluate this index for the diagnosis of acute phrenic paresis associated with interscalene block.

We designed an observational study in 22 patients scheduled for shoulder arthroscopy. Spirometry was performed (criteria of phrenic paresis was a decrease in FVC and FEV1 ≥20%). Ultrasound apposition zone was assessed in anterior axillary line and diaphragmatic displacement was evaluated on inspiration and expiration (number of intercostal spaces; phrenic paresis considered a reduction ≥25%) and thickness of the diaphragm muscle (a phrenic paresis was considered an index <1.2). These determinations were performed before and at 20min after interscalene block at C5-C6 with 20ml of 0.5% ropivacaine.

Twenty-one patients (95%) presented phrenic nerve block according to one or more of the methods used. One patient did not show any symptoms or signs suggestive of phrenic paralysis and was excluded. All the patients presented phrenic paresis based on the diaphragmatic thickness index, with the pre-block index being 1.8±0.5 and post-block of 1.05±0.06 (P<0.001). Ninety percent of the patients (19) presented phrenic paresis according to spirometry and all the patients had a reduction in diaphragmatic movement after the block (from 1.9±0.5 intercostal spaces to 0.5±0.3; P<0.001).

The index of inspiratory / expiratory diaphragmatic thickness at cut-off <1.2 seems to be useful in the diagnosis of phrenic paresis associated with interscalene block. This index does not require a baseline pre-assessment.