Factors Predicting the Recovery of Unilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis After Thyroidectomy

We used voice analysis and clinicopathological factors to explore the prognosis of unilateral vocal fold paralysis after thyroid surgery.

The medical records of 63 females who developed unilateral vocal fold paralysis after thyroidectomy were reviewed. All patients were divided into two groups: those who recovered from vocal fold paralysis and those who did not. We analyzed clinical parameters and voice analysis results in a search for correlations with recovery from paralysis.

Of the 63 patients, 37 (58%) recovered from paralysis. A small tumor size, incomplete paralysis, the absence of arytenoid tilting, no compensatory movement of the normal side, lower postoperative shimmer, a higher postoperative maximum phonation time (MPT), and lower postoperative subglottic pressure correlated significantly with recovery from vocal fold paralysis. Multivariate analysis confirmed that the absence of compensatory movement of the normal side on videostroboscopy was independently prognostic. A postoperative MPT of 6.86 appeared to be optimal for prediction of recovery. Most patients recovered within 6 months, but those with incomplete paralysis recovered about 3 months earlier. At the 12-month follow-up, the thyroidectomy-related voice questionnaire scores had returned to preoperative values in only 12 patients (19.0%); 51 patients (81.0%) did not fully recover.

Compensatory movement of the normal side evident on videostroboscopy was a poor prognostic factor. Voice analysis can be helpful in counseling vocal fold paralysis patients after thyroidectomy, and early intervention may be considered in patients who are expected to have a poor prognosis.