Estrogen 2- and 4-hydroxylase activity, catechol estrogen formation, and implications for estrogen carcinogenesis in...

Estrogen 2- and 4-hydroxylase (ESH), a microsomal enzyme which mediates the formation of catechol estrogens, has been studied in the kidneys of castrated male Syrian hamsters, a species uniquely susceptible to induction of renal carcinomas by both steroidal and stilbene estrogens. The apparent Km for estrone was 17.0 microM, and Vmax was 0.5 pmol per mg protein per min for ESH in renal microsomes derived from castrated hamsters. Different steroidal estrogen substrates exhibited decreasing catechol formation with hamster kidney microsomal preparations in the following order: estrone greater than d-equilenin greater than 17 beta-estradiol greater than equilin greater than ethynyl estradiol greater than estriol. Except for beta-dienestrol, the stilbene estrogens revealed levels of catechol formation that were similar to 17 beta-estradiol. These findings provide a rationale for the weak carcinogenic activity of ethynyl estradiol, estriol, and beta-dienestrol, since they were poor substrates for hamster renal ESH and for the relatively potent carcinogenic activity of the distal metabolite of diethylstilbestrol, indenestrol B/A, which exhibited substantial levels of o-hydroxylation when used as a substrate. Interestingly, ESH activity was significantly greater in the hamster kidney compared to corresponding rat tissue, and catechol estrogen formation was found to be 2.5- to 19-fold higher in the hamster kidney compared to the rat, using various steroidal and stilbene estrogen substrates. Moreover, the finding that a 3.5- to nearly 6-fold decrease, compared to untreated levels, in catechol formation in kidneys but not in livers of alpha-naphthoflavone-exposed hamsters, depending on the steroidal or stilbene estrogen substrate used, is consistent with the belief that the catechol estrogen pathway is pertinent to events leading to estrogen-induced renal tumorigenesis in the hamster.