Effectiveness of the International Consensus Group criteria for manual peripheral smear review
Katyayani Palur1, Surekha U Arakeri1
1Department of Pathology, BLDEU's Shri BM Patil Medical College, Vijayapura, Karnataka, India.
Insights
The International Consensus Group for Hematology Review (ICGHR) criteria significantly reduced manual peripheral smear reviews compared to laboratory-specific criteria. These ICGHR criteria show promise for clinical adoption after local validation.
Area of Science:
- Hematology
- Clinical Pathology
- Laboratory Medicine
Background:
- Automated hematology analyzers (AHAs) are essential in clinical labs, but manual peripheral smear reviews (MSR) remain crucial for detecting morphological abnormalities.
- The International Consensus Group for Hematology Review (ICGHR) developed criteria to decrease the need for MSR after AHA analysis.
Purpose of the Study:
- To evaluate the effectiveness of ICGHR criteria against in-house laboratory criteria for MSR using the Sysmex XN-1000.
- To compare the performance metrics of both sets of criteria in a clinical laboratory setting.
Main Methods:
- A prospective cross-sectional study compared ICGHR and laboratory criteria for MSR.
- 860 whole blood samples were analyzed over 19 months.
- Truth tables and tests of proportion were used to compare performance specifications.
Main Results:
- ICGHR criteria yielded 81.58% sensitivity, 84.61% specificity, and reduced the MSR rate to 47.56% with 83.14% efficiency.
- Laboratory criteria showed higher sensitivity (98.80%) but lower specificity (41.40%), with a higher MSR rate of 78.14% and 69.30% efficiency.
Conclusions:
- The ICGHR criteria significantly decrease manual smear review rates compared to traditional laboratory criteria.
- ICGHR criteria are adaptable for daily practice but require initial optimization and local validation.
Context:
The International Consensus Group for Hematology Review (ICGHR) are essentially review criteria designed to reduce the number of manual smear reviews following analysis in automated hematology analyzers (AHAs). Although AHAs are an indispensable part of the present-day clinical laboratory, manual smear reviews still play an integral role in identifying morphological abnormalities and to confirm the results of the analyzers.
Aims:
The aim of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of the ICGHR criteria and our laboratory criteria using the Sysmex XN-1000 for manual peripheral smear review (MSR).
Study Design:
A prospective cross-sectional comparative study between the two sets of criteria for MSR was performed.
Material And Methods:
A total of 860 whole blood samples sent over a period of 19 months for complete blood count testing to our laboratory were collected using systematic random sampling. Truth tables were prepared for each set of criteria. Tests of proportion were used to compare performance specifications between both sets of criteria.
Results:
Using ICGHR criteria, sensitivity was 81.58%, specificity was 84.61%, 83.38% positive predictive value, and 82.92% negative predictive value. The microscopic smear review rate was 47.56% and efficiency was 83.14%. Using our laboratory criteria, sensitivity was 98.80%, specificity was 41.40%, positive predictive value of 61.46%, and negative predictive value of 97.34%. The microscopic smear review rate was 78.14% and efficiency 69.30%.
Conclusions:
There was a significant reduction in the microscopic smear review rates using the ICGHR criteria compared to our laboratory criteria. The ICGHR criteria can thus be adapted to daily laboratory practice provided they are first optimized and locally validated before use.
Related Concept Videos
Criteria for Causality: Bradford Hill Criteria - II
Criteria for Causality: Bradford Hill Criteria - I
Chemical Shift: Internal References and Solvent Effects
The internal reference compound generally used in NMR spectroscopy is tetramethylsilane (TMS). TMS is preferred because it is chemically inert, soluble in NMR solvents, and easily removable. Also, the highly shielded methyl protons in TMS yield an intense...
Internal Receptors
Review and Preview
Percentiles are a type of fractile that partition data into...
Review and Preview


