Histologic validation of ICDAS-II and polarization sensitive optical coherence tomography to detect smooth surface...

This in vitro study aimed to histologically validate and compare the methods for detection of smooth surface early carious lesions (ECLs) that is, International caries detection and assessment system for the smooth surface (ICDAS-II-SSC), Polarization sensitive optical coherence tomography (PS-OCT), and radiography.

PS-OCT images for scores 0-3 of ICDAS-II-SSC were standardized according to ECLs' depth. Preliminary PS-OCT images for ICDAS-II-SSC score-2 of pigmented ECLs showed reduced lesion depth and therefore were dichotomized into scores 2 and 2p for white and pigmented lesions (ICDAS-II-SSCm). ECLs on one hundred freshly extracted teeth were scored by three examiners for ICDAS-II-SSCm, PS-OCT, radiography, and histology.

Compared to histology, ICDAS-II-SSCm showed a strong positive correlation followed by PS-OCT and radiographic evaluation. ICDAS-II-SSCm had a strong positive correlation with PS-OCT, while both variables had a weak positive correlation with radiography. PS-OCT detected the activity of ECLs by directly relating the image depth of ECLs to their mineral volume content.

The current scope of ICDAS-II should be reviewed since the pigmentation can be misinterpreted as an active lesion. Till then, ICDAS-II-SSC is an effective visual method for early caries detection. PS-OCT has the potential to become a probe with the proper algorithm for diagnostic purposes.