Steeper dose gradients resulting from reduced source to target distance-a planning system independent study

To quantify the contribution of penumbra in the improvement of healthy tissue sparing at reduced source-to-axis distance (SAD) for simple spherical target and different prescription isodoses (PI).

A TPS-independent method was used to estimate three-dimensional (3D) dose distribution for stereotactic treatment of spherical targets of 0.5 cm radius based on single beam two-dimensional (2D) film dosimetry measurements. 1 cm target constitutes the worst case for the conformation with standard Multi-Leaf Collimator (MLC) with 0.5 cm leaf width. The measured 2D transverse dose cross-sections and the profiles in leaf and jaw directions were used to calculate radial dose distribution from isotropic beam arrangement, for both quadratic and circular beam openings, respectively. The results were compared for standard (100 cm) and reduced SAD 70 and 55 cm for different PI.

For practical reduction of SAD using quadratic openings, the improvement of healthy tissue sparing (HTS) at distances up to 3 times the PTV radius was at least 6%-12%; gradient indices (GI) were reduced by 3-39% for PI between 40% and 90%. Except for PI of 80% and 90%, quadratic apertures at SAD 70 cm improved the HTS by up to 20% compared to circular openings at 100 cm or were at least equivalent; GI were 3%-33% lower for reduced SAD in the PI range 40%-70%. For PI = 80% and 90% the results depend on the circular collimator model.

Stereotactic treatments of spherical targets delivered at reduced SAD of 70 or 55 cm using MLC spare healthy tissue around the target at least as good as treatments at SAD 100 cm using circular collimators. The steeper beam penumbra at reduced SAD seems to be as important as perfect target conformity. The authors argue therefore that the beam penumbra width should be addressed in the stereotactic studies.