Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: How Do Current Practice Guidelines Affect Management?

International best-practice guidelines recommend completion thyroidectomy and radioiodine remnant ablation (RRA) for patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) > 4 cm or with specific risk factors. Patients with DTC < 1 cm without risk factors are recommended for lobectomy alone. Indications for aggressive surgery and RRA are less clearly defined for tumours measuring 1-4 cm. A personalised approach to decision-making is recommended.

This study assesses therapeutic approaches to DTC as compared to the current British Thyroid Association (BTA) clinical practice guidelines. We ascertained the effect of equivocal guidance in the 1-4 cm tumour cohort on contemporary practice patterns.

Data were obtained from a prospectively maintained thyroid cancer database of patients treated for DTC in a tertiary referral centre at the University Hospital Galway. Consecutive patients attending a dedicated thyroid cancer clinic between August 2014 and August 2017 were included. Clinicopathological characteristics and management strategies were assessed.

Ninety-four percent (n = 168/178) of patients were surgically managed in adherence with guidelines. A minority (n = 10) received surgery not aligned with guidelines. Ninety-seven percent (n = 172/178) of RRA treatment decisions were in accordance with guidelines. The BTA guidelines recommended a personalised decision-making approach for 18.0% (n = 32) and 44.9% (n = 80) of surgery and RRA treatment decisions, respectively. The more aggressive, treatment-driven approach was typically favoured by the multidisciplinary team, with 97% (n = 31/32) undergoing completion thyroidectomy and 100% (n = 80) proceeding to RRA.

Management of DTC at our institution closely adheres to contemporary clinical practice guidelines. The finding of more aggressive management in those requiring a personalised decision-making approach highlights the requirement for improved risk stratification in this cohort to ratio-nalise management strategies.