Diagnostic Performance of Carbon Monoxide Testing by Pulse Oximetry in the Emergency Department

Carbon monoxide (CO) exposure causes roughly 40,000 emergency department (ED) visits annually and is commonly misdiagnosed. Whereas the standard method of carboxyhemoglobin (HbCO) measurement utilizes blood gas analysis, a noninvasive, FDA-cleared alternative exists. We evaluated the performance of pulse oximetry (S_pCO) for identification of CO exposure in ED patients.

We compared pulse oximetry to blood HbCO levels in a prospective observational study of adult and pediatric subjects recruited from the ED. Nurses screened a convenience sample of patients and referred those with S_pCO ≥ 10% to research staff. Researchers also approached individuals who presented with signs and symptoms of CO toxicity. We determined diagnostic performance with a Bland-Altman analysis and calculated sensitivity and specificity for detection of elevated HbCO at thresholds of ≥ 10% and ≥ 15%. To optimize the potential sensitivity of S_pCO for detection of CO toxicity, research technicians performed 3 S_pCO readings within 5 min of the blood draw for laboratory measurement. A positive S_pCO test was defined as any S_pCO ≥ 10%.

42,000 patients were screened, 212 were evaluated, and 126 subjects were enrolled. Median HbCO level was 6% (range 1.6-21.9%). Limits of agreement were -10.3% and 8.1%. Of 23 individuals with elevated HbCO ≥ 10%, 13 were not suspected based on clinical assessment. Critically elevated HbCO was present in 6 individuals. Based on our a priori threshold of 10% for a positive test, pulse oximetry identified 14 of 23 subjects with HbCO ≥ 10%, with a sensitivity of 61% (95% CI 39-80%) and a specificity of 86% (95% CI 78-92%), and 5 of 6 subjects with HbCO ≥ 15%, with a sensitivity of 83% (95% CI 36-100%) and a specificity of 81% (95% CI 73-87%).

Pulse oximetry underestimated HbCO and produced false negative results (ie, S_pCO < 10% for all three measurements) in 17% of ED subjects with elevated HbCO ≥ 15%. Triage screening with pulse oximetry detected cases of elevated HbCO that were not suspected by the clinical provider.