"The damned behaviorist" versus French phenomenologists: Pierre Naville and the French indigenization of Watson's...

What do we know about the history of John Broadus Watson's behaviorism outside of its American context of production? In this article, using the French example, we propose a study of some of the actors and debates that structured this history. Strangely enough, it was not a "classic" experimental psychologist, but Pierre Naville (1904-1993), a former surrealist, Marxist philosopher, and sociologist, who can be identified as the initial promoter of Watson's ideas in France. However, despite Naville's unwavering commitment to behaviorism, his weak position in the French intellectual community, combined with his idiosyncratic view of Watson's work, led him to embody, as he once described himself, the figure of "the damned behaviorist." Indeed, when Naville was unsuccessfully trying to introduce behaviorism into France, alternative theories defended by philosophers such as Jean-Paul Sartre and Maurice Merleau-Ponty explicitly condemned Watson's theory and met with rapid and major success. Both existentialism and phenomenology were more in line than behaviorism with what could be called the "French national narrative" of the immediate postwar. After the humiliation of the occupation by the Nazis, the French audience was especially critical of any deterministic view of behavior that could be seen as a justification for collaboration. By contrast, Sartre's ideas about absolute freedom and Merleau-Ponty's attempt to preserve subjectivity were far more acceptable at the time. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).