Treatment results of 99 patients undergoing open partial hypopharyngectomy with larynx preservation

Hypopharyngeal cancers frequently go undetected until advanced stages. However, recent advances in endoscopic technology have enabled earlier detection of hypopharyngeal cancer. We evaluated the effectiveness of larynx-preserving surgery for hypopharyngeal cancer.

We retrospectively analyzed 99 patients with hypopharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma who underwent partial hypopharyngectomy with larynx preservation between September 1992 and December 2009 at the National Cancer Center Hospital East. Of these, 91 patients underwent larynx-preserving surgery as initial treatment; eight patients underwent salvage surgery for recurrent disease after previous radiotherapy. Also, 9 of our patients had undergone previous radiotherapy in the head and neck for a different cancer. Before surgery, the TNM stage and tumor location was recorded. Free-flap reconstruction was performed in 60 patients, while the hypopharyngeal mucosa was closed without a free flap in 39 patients.

The 5-year overall survival rate in our cohort was 66.9%, and 59 patients are currently alive without recurrence. Thirty-three patients died due to primary recurrence (n = 5), regional recurrence (n = 10), distant metastasis (n = 9), postoperative death (n = 1), and unrelated disease (n = 8). Laryngeal function could not be preserved in 19 patients, 2 of whom had undergone previous radiotherapy, and 7 of whom had undergone both previous radiotherapy and other salvage surgeries.

Partial hypopharyngectomy can preserve laryngeal function in patients with pharyngeal cancer with careful patient selection.