The impact of thoracic paravertebral block over post-operatory evolution in open lobectomy

The thoracic paravertebral block (PVB), a technique of post-thoracotomy analgesia of similar effectiveness as continuous epidural analgesia (CEA) but with a better safety profile, is underutilized in current practice. This study compares the outcome of post-lobectomy patients in relation to the analgesic method used: parenteral analgesia (PA) vs. PVB + PA, and provides justification for the routine use of PVB in all patients where CEA is contraindicated.

We randomized 213 consecutive patients undergoing open lobectomy to benefit from two different protocols of postoperative analgesia: PA vs. PVB +PA. We compared the frequency of cardiac hemodynamic, respiratory, pleural or surgical-related complications.

After lobectomy, the PVB patients (72/213) were found to have a significantly lower frequency of congestive heart failure (7.1%vs.0.0%)(p=0.049), ischemic cardiomyopathy (10.6%vs.0.0%)(p=0.010), pulmonary atelectasis (35%vs.1.1%)(p<0.001), residual pleural space (29.8%vs.15.3%)(p=0.032) and residual intrapleural blood clots (14.9%vs.1.4%)(p=0.005). Other postoperative complications, Intensive Care stay, total hospital stay and mortality rate were less frequent in the PVB group but without reaching statistical significance.

The use of SPVB is associated with significant less postoperative complications than PA only. This study suggests that the SPVB might be the ideal choice in post-thoracotomy pain management when CEA cannot be used.

Open lobectomy, Post-lobectomy, Thoracic paravertebral block.