Impact of Fragmentation on Commutability of Epstein-Barr Virus and Cytomegalovirus Quantitative Standards

Despite the adaptation of international standards, quantitative viral load testing of transplant-associated viruses continues to be limited by interlaboratory disagreement. Studies have suggested that this disagreement and the poor commutability of standards may, in some cases, be linked to amplicon size and the fragmentation of circulating viral DNA. We evaluated target fragmentation as a cause of noncommutability and pretest fragmentation of quantitative standards as a potential means of increasing commutability and interassay agreement. Forty-two cytomegalovirus (CMV)-positive and 41 Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-positive plasma samples, together with two different quantitative standards for each virus, were tested as unknowns using 10 different quantitative PCR assays at 5 different laboratories. Standards were tested both intact and after intentional fragmentation by ultrasonication. Quantitative agreement between methods was assessed, together with commutability, using multiple statistical approaches. Most assays yielded results within 0.5 log₁₀ IU/ml of the mean for CMV, while for EBV a greater variability of up to 1.5 log₁₀ IU/ml of the mean was shown. Commutability showed marked improvement following fragmentation of both CMV standards but not after fragmentation of the EBV standards. These findings confirm the impact of amplicon size and target fragmentation on commutability for CMV and suggest that for some (but not all) viruses, interlaboratory harmonization can be improved through the use of fragmented quantitative standards.