Stimulation challenge test after STN DBS improves satisfaction in Parkinson's disease patients

Although subthalamic Deep Brain Stimulation (STN DBS) is proven effective in improving symptoms of Parkinson's Disease (PD), previous literature demonstrates a discrepancy between objective improvement and patients' perception thereof. We aimed to examine whether postoperative stimulation challenge tests (SCT) alters patients' satisfaction after STN DBS for PD.

Fifty-four PD patients underwent preoperative levodopa challenge tests and were routinely invited for SCT 1-2 years postoperatively. SEverity of predominantly Nondopaminergic Symptoms in PD (SENS-PD) scores quantified non-dopaminergic disease severity. Motor functioning was quantified using Movement Disorders Society Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS) III scores; a ratio between conditions ON and OFF (preoperative Med-ON vs. Med-OFF, and postoperative Med-ON/Stim-ON vs. Med-OFF/Stim-OFF) reflected treatment benefit. 'Global Impression of Change' (GIC) and 'Global Satisfaction with Surgery' (GSS) Likert scales were filled out before and immediately after SCT.

Postoperative Med-ON/Stim-ON severity was lower than preoperative ON severity. Disease severity scores were not different between assessments. GIC and GSS scores were higher after SCT versus before (GIC: Z = -3.80, r = 0.37, subjects indicating maximum scores before SCT: 32.1%, after SCT: 57.1%; GSS: Z = -3.69, r = 0.35, maximum scores before SCT: 25.0%, after SCT: 46.4%). Higher non-dopaminergic disease severity was associated with lower GIC and GSS scores (GIC: OR 1.2 (95%CI 1.0-1.3); GSS: OR 1.2 (95%CI 1.1-1.3), while motor-scores and magnitude of DBS-effects were not.

SCT improves patients' satisfaction and is recommended especially in case of suboptimal subjective valuations. This information should be considered in clinical practice and in the context of clinical trials.