Segmentation of gliomas in ¹⁸F-fluorocholine PET/CT. A multiapproach study

Our aim was two-fold, to study the interobserver agreement in tumour segmentation and to search for a reliable methodology to segment gliomas using ¹⁸F-fluorocholine PET/CT.

25 patients with glioma, from a prospective and non-randomized study (Functional and Metabolic Glioma Analysis), were included.Interobserver variability in tumour segmentation was assessed using fixed thresholds. Different strategies were used to segment the tumours. First, a semi-automatic tumour segmentation was performed, selecting the best SUVmax-% threshold for each lesion. Next we determined a variable SUVmax-% depending on the SUVmax. Finally a segmentation using a fixed SUVmax threshold was performed. To do so, a sampling of 10 regions of interest (ROI of 2.8cm²) located in the normal brain was performed. The upper value of the sample mean SUVmax±3 SD was used as cut-off. All procedures were tested and classified as effective or not for tumour segmentation by two observer's consensus.

In the pilot segmentation, the mean±SD of SUVmax, SUVmean and optimal SUVmax-% threshold were: 3.64±1.77, 1.32±0.57 and 21.32±8.39, respectively. Optimal SUVmax-% threshold showed a significant association with the SUVmax (Pearson=-0.653, p=.002). However, the linear regression model for the total sample was not good, that supported the division in two homogeneous groups, defining two formulas for predicting the optimal SUVmax-% threshold. As to the third procedure, the obtained value for the mean SUVmax background+3 SD was 0.33. This value allowed segmenting correctly a significant fraction of tumours, although not all.

A great interobserver variability in the tumour segmentation was found. None of the methods was able to segment correctly all the gliomas, probably explained by the wide tumour heterogeneity on ¹⁸F-fluorocholine PET/CT.