Clinical Instructors' Experiences Working with and Assessing Students Who Perform below Expectations in Physical...

Clinical education is an integral component of the curriculum of all physical therapy (PT) entry-to-practice programmes in Canada. The literature indicates that working with and assessing students performing below expectations (SPBE) can be procedurally and emotionally difficult. Our study aimed to explore the experiences of clinical instructors (CIs) and the decision-making process involved when supervising SPBE in PT. A total of 19 in-depth, semi-structured interviews were conducted with CIs, transcribed, and coded using qualitative thematic analysis. Four factors appeared to be important for CIs when they were deciding how to assess SPBE: (1) features of student performance, (2) factors related to the CIs, (3) academic and clinical facility influencers, and (4) strategies and available resources. Concerns about safety and professional behaviour, a student's clinical reasoning skills, and a lack of progression were key factors that CIs considered in recommending a final grade. CIs were more likely to recommend a failing grade if there was a series of repeated incidents rather than an isolated incident. We make several recommendations for the student, CI, and facilities to consider to better support and facilitate the process of working with SPBE in PT clinical education.