Can we improve women's experience of operative vaginal birth?

It is well understood that advanced skills are required for operative vaginal delivery to ensure a woman's birth experience is safe, positive and to prevent adverse long term harm. We sought to identify non-technical skills determined by women to enhance experience of operative vaginal delivery by qualitative analysis of interviews conducted during the postpartum period.

A qualitative study using semi structured interviews took place at a University teaching hospital. Sixteen women who had an operative delivery of a term baby underwent a semi structured interview at 6-8 weeks postnatal. The women were asked to reflect on good and bad experiences of their delivery and the interview was recorded verbatim. Thematic coding of data was carried out and then analysed. Women were given the option to review the transcript for respondent validation. The anonymised transcripts were independently coded by two researchers and then compared for consistency of interpretation. The themes that emerged following the final coding were used to identify a framework of behavioural and clinical skills.

We identified several non-technical skills that were important to women's' experience of operative delivery. Professional behaviour and relationships, decision making and communication, preconceptions and preparation for operative birth, teamwork, environment and consent were themes that emerged from women's experiences which can now provide clinicians with a comprehensive behavioural framework for operative vaginal delivery.

This illustration of detailed non-technical skills that has been validated by women could be used as part of clinical training and revalidation.