Comparative study on three viral enrichment approaches based on RNA extraction for plant virus/viroid detection using...

High-throughput sequencing (HTS) has become increasingly popular as virus diagnostic tool. It has been used to detect and identify plant viruses and viroids in different types of matrices and tissues. A viral sequence enrichment method prior to HTS is required to increase the viral reads in the generated data to ease the bioinformatic analysis of generated sequences. In this study, we compared the sensitivity of three viral enrichment approaches, i.e. double stranded RNA (dsRNA), ribosomal RNA depleted total RNA (ribo-depleted totRNA) and small RNA (sRNA) for plant virus/viroid detection, followed by sequencing on MiSeq and NextSeq Illumina platforms. The three viral enrichment approaches used here enabled the detection of all viruses/viroid used in this study. When the data was normalised, the recovered viral/viroid nucleotides and depths were depending on the viral genome and the enrichment method used. Both dsRNA and ribo-depleted totRNA approaches detected a divergent strain of Wuhan aphid virus 2 that was not expected in this sample. Additionally, Vicia cryptic virus was detected in the data of dsRNA and sRNA approaches only. The results suggest that dsRNA enrichment has the highest potential to detect and identify plant viruses and viroids. The dsRNA approach used here detected all viruses/viroid, consumed less time, was lower in cost, and required less starting material. Therefore, this approach appears to be suitable for diagnostics laboratories.