A Comparative Study Between 20% Mannitol and 3% Hypertonic Saline for Brain Oedema Reduction during Elective Brain...

Cerebral oedema is an important manifestation of brain tumour. The significant reduction of cerebral oedema can show rapid improvement of the patients. Hypertonic saline solution and mannitol both are commonly used for this action. It is now time to choose the better one. This was a prospective randomized comparative study designed to evaluate the efficacy of 3% hypertonic saline (NaCl) in reduction of brain oedema during brain tumour surgery and compare it with that of 20% Mannitol. The study was conducted in the department of Anaesthesiology, Combined Military Hospital, Dhaka, Bangladesh from July 2016 to December 2016. A total number of 47 patients for brain tumour surgery were selected. After screening 40 patients were finalized. Then the patients were divided into 2 equal groups 20 patients in each. Patients of Group A received 3% hypertonic saline and Group B 20% mannitol. Uniform anaesthetic technique applied for all patients, fixed surgeon/group of surgeons carried out the surgery. Heart rate and noninvasive blood pressure were monitored and kept with in ±20% baseline values different means. ETCO2 were kept in between 28-32mm of Hg by adjusting ventilator setting. Reduction of brain oedema was monitored by subjective assessment of surgeons using a 3 point scale of brain relaxation. The data were recorded in preformed data sheet. The results were tested by chi-square test to see their level of significance i.e. p value <0.05 was considered as significant. At the opening of dura, the number of brain conditions classified as soft, adequate and tight were statistically non-significant between groups. After 0.5 hour and 1.0 hour 10% patient's brain was tight in Group A whereas it was 35% and 40% in Group B respectively. Reduction of brain oedema or brain relaxation was significantly better in Group A compared to Group B (p<0.05). Urine output was higher with mannitol than hypertonic saline (p<0.05). Duration of ICU and hospital stay in both Group A and Group B were statistically similar (p>0.05). Compared to mannitol, hypertonic saline caused an increase in serum sodium concentration over time (p<0.05). From the available data, use of 20% mannitol and 3% hypertonic saline for brain oedema reduction, it is suggested that hypertonic saline significantly reduces the risk of tight brain and produce the brain more soft than mannitol during brain tumour surgery.