Increased conceptual switching by dopaminergic treatment in patients with Parkinson's disease

Cognitive changes including reduced word production in verbal fluency (VF) tasks are frequently observed in Parkinson's disease (PD) with ambiguous effects of dopaminergic medication on these symptoms. Here, we studied the impact of dopaminergic medication on specific cognitive components underlying VF task performance in 21 participants with PD on their regular medication and following dopamine withdrawal compared with healthy controls. We used temporal cluster analysis (TCA) to differentiate phases of VF output relating to fast automatic lexical activation ('clusters') and slower attention-demanding shifts ('switches'). Dopaminergic medication led to increased switching and, in non-alternating VF tasks, to the formation of smaller and shorter word clusters. The number of switches was correlated with higher cognitive scores and showed an inverse relationship with VF error rates. Increased switching operations during VF task performance can be interpreted in view of nigrostriatal dopaminergic roles for balancing system state versus change propensities. The additional effect on word clustering suggests a modulation of semantic spreading activation mechanisms underlying lexical search, presumably involving non-nigrostriatal, e.g., mesocortical dopaminergic networks.