Accurate and cost-effective mandibular biomodels: a standardized evaluation of 3D-Printing via fused layer deposition...

Medical biomodels can be used for illustration of medical conditions, preoperative planning or to facilitate pre-bending of osteosynthesis material. They have been shown to be an effective and efficient method to reduce operating time, blood loss and wound stress in cranio-maxillo-facial surgery. Lately, new time and cost-efficient 3D-printing methods have been introduced into the mass-market. The aim of this study was to establish a standardized method of evaluation and consequently evaluate Fused Layer Deposition Modeling in combination with soluble support structures for fabrication of medical biomodels regarding precision and cost-effectiveness.

Twenty-one biomodels of human mandibles equipped with measuring appliances were printed on a FLDM 3D-printers (Ultimaker 3 Extended) using a polyactate filament and a water-soluble Polyvinyl alcohol-based support structures. Precision of these models was compared to commercial, polyamide sintered models and the planning data. Production costs, printing times and post processing procedures were evaluated.

Duration of printing of mandibular biomodels was between 6 h 5 min - 15 h 9 min (mean 9 h 12 min, ±2 h 25 min). The average cost of materials was €5.90 (± €1.28) per model. With an average aberrance of 0.29 mm, FLDM printing delivered a high level of accuracy. It was significantly superior to the polyamide reference models in the area of the semilunar incision, yet inferior at the coronoid process.

FLDM printers are able to provide very precise biomodels at very low costs. The use of using soluble support structures reduces time, costs and equipment needed for post processing procedures close to zero.