Numerosity Identification Used to Assess Tactile Stimulation Methods for Communication

Finger-Braille is a tactile communication method used by people who are Deafblind. Individuals communicate Finger-Braille messages with combinations of taps on three fingers of each of the hands of the person receiving the communication. Devices have been developed to produce Finger-Braille symbols using different tactile stimulation methods. Before engaging in communication studies based on technologically-mediated Finger-Braille, we evaluated the relative efficacy of these methods by comparing two devices similarly constructed; the first based on widely employed eccentric rotating-mass vibrating motors and the other using specifically designed tapping actuators. We asked volunteers to identify the numerosity of presented items and for each device we measured (1) error-rate, (2) reaction time, (3) confidence ratings, and (4) a comparison of confidence ratings to actual performance. The four measures obtained for each device showed a net advantage of the tapping stimulation method over the method of vibrations. In this article, we conclude that the tapping stimulation method is recommended for use in the design of tactile communication devices based on Finger-Braille and fingerspelling methods reliant on finger tapping actions. The results did not demonstrate clear evidence for tactile subitising with passively experienced stimulation on the fingers.