Characterizing and circumventing sequence restrictions for synthesis of circular RNA in vitro

Just as eukaryotic circular RNA (circRNA) is a product of intracellular backsplicing, custom circRNA can be synthesized in vitro using a transcription template in which transposed halves of a split group I intron flank the sequence of the RNA to be circularized. Such permuted intron-exon (PIE) constructs have been used to produce circRNA versions of ribozymes, mimics of viral RNA motifs, a streptavidin aptamer, and protein expression vectors for genetic engineering and vaccine development. One limitation of this approach is the obligatory incorporation of small RNA segments (E1 and E2) into nascent circRNA at the site of end-joining. This restriction may preclude synthesis of small circRNA therapeutics and RNA nanoparticles that are sensitive to extraneous sequence, as well as larger circRNA mimics whose sequences must precisely match those of the native species on which they are modelled. In this work, we used serial mutagenesis and in vitro selection to determine how varying E1 and E2 sequences in a thymidylate synthase (td) group I intron PIE transcription template construct affects circRNA synthesis yield. Based on our collective findings, we present guidelines for the design of custom-tailored PIE transcription templates from which synthetic circRNAs of almost any sequence may be efficiently synthesized.