Ten highly sensitive thyrotropin assays compared by receiver-operating characteristic curves analysis: results of a...

We report a prospective multicenter study, undertaken to compare the efficacy of 10 highly sensitive thyrotropin assay kits for the diagnosis of hyperthyroidism. Performances of the kits were compared with a reference diagnosis based on clinical examination, pertinent biological tests, and determination by an independent laboratory of the concentrations in serum of free triiodothyronine and free thyroxin. No thyrotropin determination was used in establishing this reference diagnosis. Receiver-operating characteristic curves were obtained for results from 600 patients (217 hyperthyroid and 383 euthyroid) by each kit. Even though analyses were performed out of the working range of most kits, the clinical correlation was nevertheless excellent. The best results corresponded to a sensitivity of 97.5% associated with a specificity of 96.1% and were significantly better than those obtained with all other kits. Results of this comparison depended greatly on the heterogeneity of the "normal"/"abnormal" categories. When only diffuse hyperthyroidism was considered, sensitivity and specificity were improved for all kits, and there was no significant difference among the five best kits.