Middle Vault Changes After Humpectomy by Spare Roof Technique Versus Component Dorsal Hump Reduction

Objectives: To compare the effect of two different humpectomy techniques in the internal nasal valve (INV) angle in human anatomic specimens. Methods: Seven human anatomic specimens (14 heminoses) were included. A strip of subdorsal septal cartilage was removed and, in each nose, the right side of the middle roof lied intact over and was sutured to the septal cartilage (spare roof technique [SRT]), whereas in the left side the upper lateral cartilage was folded and sutured to the septal cartilage (component dorsal hump reduction [CDHR]). The INV angle was measured pre- and postoperatively. Results: Mean age of the specimens was 69.86 (60-80) years. Five were female. CDHR resulted in a mean change of +1.71 ± 3.12° (p = 0.197), +0.62 ± 6.89° (p = 0.817) and +6.97 ± 6.84° (p = 0.036) after resection of 2, 4, and 6 mm of septal cartilage, respectively. SRT resulted in a mean change of +1.27 ± 2.37° (p = 0.207), +6.89 ± 1.19° (p < 0.001), and +12.55 ± 1.79° (p < 0.001) after resection of 2, 4, and 6 mm of septal cartilage, respectively. In SRT, the amount of septal cartilage resection presented a significant correlation with change in INV angle (r = 0.813, p < 0.001). Conclusions: In this human anatomic study, SRT significantly increased INV angle.