Linear-Response and Nonlinear-Response Formulations of the Instantaneous Marcus Theory for Nonequilibrium...

Instantaneous Marcus theory (IMT) offers a way for capturing the time-dependent charge transfer (CT) rate coefficient in nonequilibrium photoinduced CT processes, where the system was photoexcited from its equilibrated ground state vertically to the excitonic state, followed by an electronic transition to the CT state. As derived from the linearized semiclassical nonequilibrium Fermi's golden rule (LSC NE-FGR), the original IMT requires expensive all-atom nonequilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD) simulations. In this work, we propose computationally efficient linear-response and nonlinear-response formulations for IMT rate calculations, which only require equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. The linear- and nonlinear-response IMT methods were tested to predict the transient behavior in the photoinduced CT dynamics of the carotenoid-porphyrin-C₆₀ molecular triad solvated in explicit tetrahydrofuran. Our result demonstrated that the nonlinear-response IMT is in excellent agreement with the benchmark NEMD for all cases investigated here, whereas the linear-response IMT predicts the correct trend for all cases but overestimates the transient CT rate in one case involving a significant nonequilibrium relaxation. This mild breakdown of linear-response IMT is due to neglecting the higher-order terms in the exact nonlinear-response IMT. Taking advantage of time translational symmetry, the linear- and nonlinear-response approaches were demonstrated to be able to reduce the computational cost by 80% and 60% compared with NEMD simulations, respectively. Thus, we highly recommend the readily applicable and accurate nonlinear-response IMT approach for simulating nonequilibrium CT processes in complex molecular systems in the condensed phase.