Commitment to Change Statements and Actual Practice Change After a Continuing Medical Education Intervention

Continuing medical education (CME) interventions often evaluate participant commitment to change (CTC) clinical practice. Evidence linking CTC to actual practice change is limited.

In an intervention that combined live CME with changes to the electronic health record to promote judicious antibiotic use for children with urinary tract infections (UTIs), we evaluated CTC and subsequent prescribing behavior in Kaiser Permanente Colorado, an integrated health care system. CTC was assessed immediately after the session using closed-ended questions about session learning objectives and open-ended questions to elicit specific practice changes. Perceived barriers to implementing recommended changes were also assessed.

Among 179 participants, 80 (45%) completed postsession evaluations and treated one or more child with a UTI in the subsequent 17 months (856 UTIs in total). In closed-ended responses about session learning objectives, 45 clinicians (56%) committed to changing practice for antibiotic choice and duration, whereas 37 (46%) committed to implementing new practice guidelines. When asked open-ended questions to identify specific practice changes, 32 (40%) committed to antibiotic choice change and 29 (36%) committed to treatment duration change. Participants who made specific CTC statements had greater improvement in antibiotic choice (relative rate ratio 1.56, 95% CI 1.16-2.09) and duration (relative rate ratio 1.59, 95% CI 1.05-2.41) than participants who did not make specific commitments. Few perceived barriers affected subsequent prescribing.

Commitments to changing specific clinical behaviors were associated with sustained changes in prescribing for children with UTIs. Linking self-evaluations with clinical data in integrated health care systems is an important tool for CME evaluators.