Sleep spindles comprise a subset of a broader class of electroencephalogram events

Sleep spindles are defined based on expert observations of waveform features in the electroencephalogram (EEG) traces. This is a potentially limiting characterization, as transient oscillatory bursts like spindles are easily obscured in the time domain by higher amplitude activity at other frequencies or by noise. It is therefore highly plausible that many relevant events are missed by current approaches based on traditionally defined spindles. Given their oscillatory structure, we reexamine spindle activity from first principles, using time-frequency activity in comparison to scored spindles.

Using multitaper spectral analysis, we observe clear time-frequency peaks in the sigma (10-16 Hz) range (TFσ peaks). While nearly every scored spindle coincides with a TFσ peak, numerous similar TFσ peaks remain undetected. We therefore perform statistical analyses of spindles and TFσ peaks using manual and automated detection methods, comparing event cooccurrence, morphological similarities, and night-to-night consistency across multiple datasets.

On average, TFσ peaks have more than three times the rate of spindles (mean rate: 9.8 vs. 3.1 events/minute). Moreover, spindles subsample the most prominent TFσ peaks with otherwise identical spectral morphology. We further demonstrate that detected TFσ peaks have stronger night-to-night rate stability (ρ = 0.98) than spindles (ρ = 0.67), while covarying with spindle rates across subjects (ρ = 0.72).

These results provide compelling evidence that traditionally defined spindles constitute a subset of a more generalized class of EEG events. TFσ peaks are therefore a more complete representation of the underlying phenomenon, providing a more consistent and robust basis for future experiments and analyses.