The Effect of Malunited Scaphoid Fractures on Joint Congruency

Although the consequences of scaphoid nonunion have been well-established, the implications of malunions are not well-known. To date, malunions have mainly been studied with 2-dimensional imaging. The objective of this study was to employ 3-dimensional computed tomography (CT) imaging and inter-bone distance mapping to determine the implications of a scaphoid malunion on 3-dimensional joint surface area (JSA) (a measure of joint contact area) at an average of 7 ± 2 years (range, 4-12 years) after fracture.

In 14 subjects with previous unilateral, malunited scaphoid fractures, we measured the 3-dimensional JSA using reconstructed CT bone models of the carpus. The JSA was compared within each individual, comparing images of the wrist collected at the time of fracture (baseline) and 7 years later (follow-up CT scans).

There was a significant increase in the measured JSA (reduced joint space) at the scaphotrapezial (23% increase) and scaphocapitate (13% increase) joints when the baseline and follow-up scans of the wrist were compared. An increased JSA indicates that the 2 opposing surfaces are closer in contact and have a reduced joint spacing reflective of degenerative changes. However, participants in this study showed no radiographic signs of degenerative changes in the wrists at midterm follow-up.

An increase in JSA was found in patients with a malunited scaphoid in the scaphotrapezial and scaphocapitate joints of the wrist an average of 7 years after injury, but these joint changes were not evident in measured radiographic signs of arthritis.

As early as 4 years after injury, the 3-dimensional JSA is significantly increased at the scaphocapitate and scaphotrapezial joints. Future work is needed to determine the implication of this increased in 3-dimensional JSA on the underlying subchondral bone, and to observe these patients for longer to determine whether degenerative changes develop.