[Advances in the application of affinity separation for analyzing protein ubiquitination]

Protein ubiquitination is one of the most common yet complex post-translational modifications in eukaryotes that plays an important role in various biological processes including cell signal transduction, growth, and metabolism. Disorders in the ubiquitination process have been revealed to correlate with the occurrence and development of many diseases such as neurodegenerative disease, inflammation, and cancer. Investigation of protein ubiquitination is of great importance to uncover protein functions, understand the molecular mechanisms underlying biological processes, and develop novel strategies for disease treatment. Great advances have been made toward understanding protein ubiquitination; however, it remains a challenging task due to the high diversity of ubiquitination sites and structures, as well as the dynamic nature of ubiquitination in biological processes. Protein ubiquitination occurs through the formation of a covalent bond between the carboxyl terminus of ubiquitin and the ε-amino group of a lysine residue in the substrate. As a small protein, ubiquitin itself can be further modified by another ubiquitin molecule to form homotypic or heterotypic polyubiquitin chains. There are eight sites, namely seven lysine residues (K6, K11, K27, K29, K33, K48, and K63) and one N-terminal methionine (M1), in one ubiquitin molecule that can be used to form a ubiquitin dimer. The variations in modification sites, ubiquitin chain lengths, and conformations result in differences in protein sorting, cell signaling, and function. To resolve the high complexity of protein ubiquitination, new separation approaches are required. Affinity separation based on the specific recognition between biomolecules offers high selectivity and has been employed to study the structures and functions of ubiquitination. In addition, affinity ligands are central to the separation performance. Different affinity ligands have been developed and employed for the capture and enrichment of ubiquitylated proteins. Immunoaffinity separation based on antigen-antibody interactions has been one of the most classical separation methods. Antibodies against ubiquitin or different ubiquitin linkages have been developed and widely applied for the enrichment of ubiquitylated proteins or peptides. The specific capture allows the downstream identification of endogenous ubiquitination sites via mass spectrometry and thus facilitates understanding of the roles and dynamics of polyubiquitin signals. Ubiquitin-binding domains (UBDs) are a collection of modular protein domains that can interact with ubiquitin or polyubiquitin chains. Ubiquitin-associated domains, ubiquitin-interacting motifs, and ubiquitin-binding zinc finger domains are the most frequently used UBDs. Due to the moderate affinity of UBDs toward ubiquitin or ubiquitin chains, tandem ubiquitin-binding entities (TUBEs) have been engineered with high affinities (K_d in the nanomolar range) and exhibit potential as powerful tools for ubiquitination analysis. Because of their affinity and selectivity, UBDs and TUBEs have been applied for the isolation and identification of ubiquitylated targets in cancer cells and yeasts. Compared with antibodies and UBDs, peptides are smaller in size and can be facilely synthesized via chemical approaches. The modular structure of peptides allows for de novo design and screening of artificial ubiquitin affinity ligands for targeted capture of ubiquitinated proteins. Furthermore, the polyhistidine tag at the N-terminus of ubiquitin facilitates the purification of ubiquitylated substrates using immobilized metal affinity chromatography. Considering the high complexity of biosystems, strategies combining multiple affinity ligands have emerged to further improve separation efficiency and reduce background interference. Several combinations of antibodies with UBDs, antibodies with peptidyl tags, and UBDs with peptidyl tags have been developed and proven to be effective for the analysis of protein ubiquitination. These affinity-based approaches serve as important solutions for studying the structure-activity relationship of protein ubiquitination. This review highlights the applications and recent advances in affinity separation techniques for analyzing protein ubiquitination, focusing on the methods using antibodies, UBDs, peptides, and their combinations as affinity ligands. Further, their applications in the enrichment of ubiquitin-modified substrates and the identification of ubiquitination structures are introduced. Additionally, remaining challenges in affinity separation of protein ubiquitination and perspectives are discussed.