Native Bacterial Community Convergence in Augmented and Stimulated Ureolytic MICP Biocementation

Microbially induced calcite precipitation is a biomineralization process with numerous civil engineering and ground improvement applications. In replicate soil columns, the efficacy and microbial composition of soil bioaugmented with the ureolytic bacterium Sporosarcina pasteurii were compared to a biostimulation method that enriches native ureolytic soil bacteria in situ under conditions analogous to field implementation. The selective enrichment resulting from sequential stimulation treatments strongly selected for Firmicutes (>97%), with Sporosarcina and Lysinibacillus comprising 60 to 94% of high-throughput 16S rDNA sequences in each suspended community sample. Seven species of the former and two of the latter were present in greater than 10% abundance at different times, demonstrating unexpected within-genus diversity and robustness in the suspended phase of this highly selective environment. Based on longer 16S sequences, it was inferred that augmented S. pasteurii competed poorly with natural bacteria, decreasing to below detection after nine treatments, while the native microbial community was enriched to approximately that present in the stimulated columns. These analyses were corroborated by the observed convergence in bulk ureolytic rates and calcite contents between techniques. However, a 10-fold discrepancy between the observed cell density and an activity-based estimate indicates the attached community, uncharacterized despite efforts, substantially contributes to bulk behavior.