Chondroinductive Peptides for Cartilage Regeneration

Inducing and maintaining a hyaline cartilage phenotype are the greatest challenge for cartilage regeneration. Synthetic chondroinductive biomaterials might be the answer to the unmet clinical need for a safe, stable, and cost-effective material capable of inducing true hyaline cartilage formation. The past decade witnessed an emergence of peptides to achieve chondrogenesis, as peptides have the advantages of versatility, high target specificity, minimized toxicity and immunogenicity, and ease of synthesis. In this study, we review peptides as the basis for creating promising synthetic chondroinductive biomaterials for in situ scaffold-based cartilage regeneration. We provide a thorough review of peptides evaluated for cartilage regeneration while distinguishing between peptides reported to induce chondrogenesis independently, and peptides reported to act in synergy with other growth factors to induce cartilage regeneration. In addition, we highlight that most peptide studies have been in vitro, and appropriate controls are not always present. A few rigorously performed in vitro studies have proceeded to in vivo studies, but the peptides in those in vivo studies were mainly introduced through systemic, subcutaneous, or intra-articular injections, with a paucity of studies employing in situ defects with appropriate controls. Clinical translation of peptides will require the evaluation of these peptides in well-controlled in vivo cartilage defect studies. In the decade ahead, we may be poised to leverage peptides to design devices that are safe, reproducible, cost-efficient, and scalable biomaterials, which are themselves chondroinductive to achieve true hyaline cartilage regeneration without the need for growth factors and other small molecules. Impact statement The regeneration of articular cartilage into its original structural, functional, and organizational hyaline phenotype remains a significant problem in the tissue engineering and orthopedic community. While cell-based solutions have shown promising outcomes, there are realistic translational challenges inherent to cell therapies. Alternatively, biomaterials have been widely studied and used as scaffolds to support and facilitate cartilage regeneration; however, the key technical challenge is to independently induce cartilage regeneration. The search for chondroinductive compounds and materials is an emerging area of research with peptides at its heart, which presents a timely opportunity to review and highlight peptides with cartilage regenerative activity and to fill gaps from previous reviews. The content of this review will serve as a valuable guide for researchers pursuing the discovery of new chondroinductive peptides or looking into incorporating the most promising existing peptides in their work.