Extraordinary claims, extraordinary evidence? A discussion
Richard M Shiffrin1, Dora Matzke2, Jonathon D Crystal1
1Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, USA.
Learning & Behavior
|August 11, 2021
Summary
The publication of surprising scientific findings, like honeybees performing arithmetic, requires careful consideration. A debate arose regarding the criteria for publishing results that challenge common understanding.
Area of Science:
- Cognitive Science
- Animal Behavior
- Publication Ethics
Background:
- Honeybee cognition research has presented findings, such as arithmetic capabilities, that challenge conventional understanding.
- Such claims may be met with skepticism by readers, editors, and reviewers.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore the criteria for publishing scientific results that are potentially viewed as unlikely.
- To use the example of honeybee arithmetic research as a case study for this debate.
Main Methods:
- The study is primarily a theoretical debate and discussion.
- It analyzes the implications of Roberts' (2020) commentary on honeybee arithmetic.
Main Results:
- The central outcome is a discussion on the standards for publishing extraordinary scientific claims.
- It highlights the tension between novel findings and the need for rigorous validation.
Conclusions:
- Establishing clear publication criteria for unlikely results is crucial for scientific integrity.
- The debate underscores the importance of balancing openness to new discoveries with critical evaluation.
More Related Videos
06:42Continuous Theta Burst Stimulation of the Posterior Medial Frontal Cortex to Experimentally Reduce Ideological Threat Responses
Published on: September 28, 2018
11.8K
09:49Holistic Facial Composite Creation and Subsequent Video Line-up Eyewitness Identification Paradigm
Published on: December 24, 2015
14.4K
Related Concept Videos
01:23Extrasensory Perception
501
Extrasensory perception, or ESP, suggests the ability to perceive events beyond the conventional senses of sight, hearing, and touch. Parapsychologists, who research ESP and related psychic phenomena, categorize ESP into three main types: precognition, telepathy, and clairvoyance.
Precognition involves foreseeing future events, such as predicting an accident before it happens. An example of precognition could be someone dreaming about a specific event, like a car crash, which then occurs...
Precognition involves foreseeing future events, such as predicting an accident before it happens. An example of precognition could be someone dreaming about a specific event, like a car crash, which then occurs...
501
01:16Unusual Results
3.4K
Unusual results are those that have a very low chance of occurring. Unusual results can be identified using probabilities and the range rule of thumb. In problems involving probability, unusual results can be observed in 2 instances – an unusually high number of successes or an unusually low number of successes.
According to the range rule of thumb, any value above or below two standard deviations, 2σ from the mean, μ is considered unusual.
Maximum unusual value =...
According to the range rule of thumb, any value above or below two standard deviations, 2σ from the mean, μ is considered unusual.
Maximum unusual value =...
3.4K
02:55The Evidence for Evolution
45.3K
Genetic variations accumulating within populations over generations give rise to biological evolution. Evolutionary changes can result in the formation of novel varieties and entire new species. These changes are responsible for the diverse forms of life inhabiting the planet. The evidence for evolution suggests that all living organisms descended from common ancestors.
45.3K
01:29Magical Thinking
26
Magical thinking encompasses the belief in assumptions that defy logical reasoning yet appear intuitively convincing. It is a common psychological phenomenon that persists across various cultural and individual contexts. While these assumptions contradict empirical evidence and scientific laws, they often serve meaningful psychological roles in promoting emotional resilience and a sense of control, especially under stress or uncertainty.Thought-Action Fusion and the Law of SimilarityA key...
26
01:19Testing a Claim about Standard Deviation
2.6K
A complete procedure to test a claim about population standard deviation or population variance is explained here.
The hypothesis testing for the claim of population standard deviation (or variance) requires the data and samples to be random and unbiased. The population distribution also must be normal. There is no specific requirement on the sample size as the estimation is based on the chi-square distribution.
As a first step, the hypothesis (null and alternative) concerning the claim about...
The hypothesis testing for the claim of population standard deviation (or variance) requires the data and samples to be random and unbiased. The population distribution also must be normal. There is no specific requirement on the sample size as the estimation is based on the chi-square distribution.
As a first step, the hypothesis (null and alternative) concerning the claim about...
2.6K
01:22Eyewitness Memory
222
Eyewitness memory refers to the recollection of events by someone who has directly witnessed them, often serving as critical evidence in legal settings. This type of memory is commonly used in criminal cases where a witness describes details like a suspect's appearance, clothing, or behavior during a crime. However, despite its perceived reliability, eyewitness memory is prone to significant errors.
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
222