Full cardiac cycle asynchronous temporal compounding of 3D echocardiography images

It is important to improve echocardiography image quality, because the accuracy of echocardiographic assessment and diagnosis relies on image quality. Previous work on 2D temporal image compounding for image frames with matching cardiac phases (synchronous), and for temporally neighbouring image frames (asynchronous) over small ranges of time frames showed good improvement to image quality. Here, we extend this by performing asynchronous temporal compounding to echocardiographic images in 3D, involving all frames within a cardiac cycle, via a robust 3D cardiac motion estimation algorithm to describe the large image deformations. After compounding, the images can be reanimated via the motion model. Various methods of fusing image frames together are tested, including mean, max, and wavelet methods, and outlier rejection algorithms. The compounding algorithm is applied on 3D human adult, porcine adolescent, and human fetal echocardiography images. Results show significant improvements to contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and boundary clarity, and significantly decreased variability in manual quantification of cardiac chamber volumes after compounding. Interestingly, compounding can extend the field of view of the echo images, by reconstructing cardiac structures that momentarily exceeded the field of view, using the motion estimation algorithm to calculate their locations outside the field of view during these time periods. Although all compounding methods provide general improvements, the mean method led to blurred boundaries, while the max methods led to high variability of CNR. Outlier rejection algorithms were found to be useful in addressing these weaknesses.