Decreasing Incisional Hernia by Teaching 4:1 Suture to Wound Length Ratio Early in Surgical Education

Incisional hernia formation has become a major burden for our healthcare system. One factor that has been shown to reduce incisional hernia rates that can be impacted on by the surgeon is the ability to achieve a 4:1 suture to wound length ratio. The purpose of this study is to evaluate whether a focused educational program for surgical residents can help improve laparotomy closures and be successful in achieving 4:1 suture to wound length ratios.

Following Institutional Review Board approval, consecutive abdominal wall closures were reviewed from December 2013 to July 2016. S:W length ratios were calculated in all cases and after 100 cases a formal audit of success and risk factors for not achieving a 4:1 ratio was performed followed by a formal resident education on laparotomy closure. The ability to achieve a 4:1 ratio for the first 100 cases following resident education was then compared to the 100 patients preceding the education with a p-value of <0.05 considered significant.

Two hundred patients underwent midline laparotomy with S:W length ratio calculated. In the first 100 patients, 76% of patients received a 4:1 S:W closure. Following resident education, this improved to 90% in the second 100 patients (p = 0.0083). Among patients where 2 residents performed the abdominal closure, 50% got an adequate 4:1 closure. This improved to 92% for the second 100 patients (p = 0.016).

A 4:1 S:W length ratio is a simple technique that has been proven to decrease incisional hernia. It requires no additional cost and can easily be implemented into practice. The act of formal resident education and measuring suture tails to calculate a S:W ratio on each case holds surgeons accountable and improves success rate of achieving a 4:1 ratio.