Foundations for a Realism-Based Ontology of Protein Aggregates

The objective of this paper is to propose formal definitions for the terms 'protein aggregate' and 'protein-containing complex' such that the descriptions and usages of these terms in biomedical literature are unified and that those portions of reality are correctly represented. To this end, we surveyed the literature to assess the need for a distinction between these entities, then compared the features of usages and definitions found in the literature to the definitions for those terms found in Bioportal ontologies. Based on the results of this comparison, we propose updated definitions for the terms 'protein aggregate' and 'protein-containing complex'. Thus far, we propose the following distinguishing factors: first, that one important difference lies in whether an entity is disposed to change type in response to certain structural alterations, such as dissociation of a continuant part, and second that an important difference lies in the ability of the entity to realize its function after such an event occurs. These distinctions are reflected in the proposed definitions.