Dispersal, not vicariance, explains the biogeographic origin of iguanas on Madagascar

Lizards of the clade Iguanidae (sensu lato) are primarily a New World group. Thus, the remarkable presence of an endemic lineage of iguanas (family Opluridae) on the isolated Indian Ocean island of Madagascar has long been considered a biogeographic anomaly. Previous work attributed this disjunct extant distribution to: (1) vicariance at about 140-165 Ma, caused by the breakup of Gondwana and the separation of South America, Africa, and Madagascar (with subsequent extinction of iguanas on Africa, and potentially other Gondwanan landmasses), (2) vicariance at about 80-90 Ma, caused by the sundering of hypothesized land-bridge connections between South America, Antarctica, India, and Madagascar, or (3) long-distance overwater dispersal from South America to Madagascar. Each hypothesis has been supported with molecular divergence dating analyses, and thus the biogeographic origin of the Opluridae is not yet well resolved. Here we utilize genetic sequences of ultraconserved elements for all Iguania families and the majority of Iguanidae (s.l.) genera, and morphological data for extant and fossil taxa (used for divergence dating analyses), to produce the most comprehensive dataset applied to date to test these origin hypotheses. We find strong support for a sister relationship between the Opluridae (Madagascar) and Leiosauridae (South America). Divergence of the Opluridae from Leiosauridae is dated to between the late Cretaceous and mid-Paleogene, at a time when Madagascar was already an island and was isolated from all other Gondwanan landmasses. Consequently, our results support a hypothesis of long-distance overwater dispersal of the Opluridae lineage, either directly from South America to Madagascar or potentially via Antarctica or Africa, leading to this radiation of iguanas in the Indian Ocean.