Characterization of the Key Odorants Causing the Musty and Fusty/Muddy Sediment Off-Flavors in Olive Oils

Microbial spoilage of olive fruits is among the most frequent reasons for two types of off-flavors in olive oils, assigned as musty and fusty/muddy sediment. To characterize both off-flavors on a molecular level by means of the sensomics approach, the key aroma compounds in a premium extra virgin olive oil (PreOO1) eliciting the typical sensory properties were compared to those identified in two off-flavor olive oils obtained from the International Olive Council (IOC). A comparative aroma extract dilution analysis (cAEDA) followed by identification experiments revealed 53 odorants in the musty reference olive oil (MusOO1) and 48 odorants in the fusty/muddy sediment one (FusOO1). Odorants, differing in flavor dilution (FD) factors or showing a high FD factor in at least one of the olive oils, were quantitated by stable isotope dilution analysis (SIDA), followed by the calculation of odor activity values (OAVs; ratio of concentration of an odorant to the respective odor threshold in odorless refined sunflower oil). Aroma recombination and omission experiments revealed 13 key aroma compounds in MusOO1 and 12 in FusOO1. To demonstrate the importance of volatile phenols, 10 phenolic smelling odorants were quantitated in further 13 extra virgin olive oils, in 3 musty and in 13 fusty/muddy sediment defective olive oils, and in 8 olive oils with other off-flavors. Both sensory defects could successfully be discriminated from extra virgin olive oils by applying either a principal component analysis or a hierarchical cluster analysis. Considering possible reaction pathways and all results obtained including Pearson coefficients between the odorant concentrations and the intensities of the defects, specifically 2-methoxyphenol and 4-ethylphenol were proposed as marker compounds for the quality assignment of both types of off-flavors induced by microbial spoilage among the identified key aroma compounds.