Screening by Self-Report Underestimates Sickle Cell Trait in High-School Athletes

Sickle cell trait (SCT) has received attention as a cause of death in college athletes, leading to mandatory lab SCT screening in National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) athletes. High-school athletes are commonly screened by self-report. There are no known studies for evaluating whether this method is effective as a screening tool.

The local prevalence rate of SCT as self-reported on the preparticipation evaluation (PPE) forms would be lower than the national accepted average.

PPE forms from the Department of Orthopedics and Rehabilitation of the University of Florida (UF) were reviewed between January 1, 2017, and April 30, 2018. The Florida High School PPE form includes a yes/no question to assess the diagnosis of SCT. The prevalence established by self-report was then compared with the national prevalence for SCT in the comparable race/ethnicity groups reported by the CDC. The response rate of SCT questions was also compared to other common cardiac screening questions.

A total of 401 forms were reviewed. Six (1.5%) students answered "yes," 351 answered "no," and 44 left the SCT question blank. All six athletes who self-reported "yes" were Black and made up 3.7% of the 162 known Black respondents. This self-report rate for Black/African Americans was well below the expected 7.3% described by the CDC. Response rates were also lower than the comparable cardiac screening questions.

Self-report SCT status rates are lower than the accepted prevalence in a similar population. Significant inconsistencies in reporting were also determined.

This is a rare study to evaluate the self-reported prevalence of SCT in high-school athletes. Below average reporting of SCT and inconsistency in completion of the forms increase the concern for accuracy and effectiveness of current high-school SCT screening methods relying on self-report.