Video Coaching in Surgical Education: Utility, Opportunities, and Barriers to Implementation

This review discusses the literature on Video-Based Coaching (VBC) and explores the barriers to widespread implementation.

A search was performed on Scopus and PubMed for the terms "operation," "operating room," "surgery," "resident," "house staff," "graduate medical education," "teaching," "coaching," "assessment," "reflection," "camera," and "video" on July 27, 2021, in English. This yielded 828 results. A single author reviewed the titles and abstracts and eliminated any results that did not pertain to operative VBC or assessment. All bibliographies were reviewed, and appropriate manuscripts were included in this study. This resulted in a total of 52 manuscripts included in this review.

Original, peer-reviewed studies focused on VBC or assessment.

VBC has been both subjectively and objectively found to be a valuable educational tool. Nearly every study of video recording in the operating room found that subjects, including surgical residents and seasoned surgeons alike, overwhelmingly considered it a useful, non-redundant adjunct to their training. Most studies that evaluated skill acquisition via standardized assessment tools found that surgical residents who underwent a VBC program had significant improvements compared to their counterparts who did not undergo video review. Despite this evidence of effectiveness, fewer than 5% of residency programs employ video recording in the operating room. Barriers to implementation include significant time commitments for proposed coaching curricula and difficulty with integration of video cameras into the operating room.

VBC has significant educational benefits, but a scalable curriculum has not been developed. An optimal solution would ensure technical ease and expediency, simple, high-quality cameras, immediate review, and overcoming entrenched surgical norms and culture.