A secondary assessment of sediment trapping effectiveness by vegetated buffers

Vegetated buffers and filter strips are a widely used Best Management Practice (BMP) for enhancing streamside ecosystem quality and water quality improvement through nonpoint source pollutant removal. Most existing studies are either site-specific, rely on limited data points, or evaluate buffer width and slope as the only design variables for predicting sediment reduction, not considering other parameters such as soil texture, vegetation types, and runoff loads that can significantly influence the buffer efficiency. In this paper, we carry out a meta-analysis of published studies and fit regression models to explore the sediment removal capacity of riparian buffers. We compiled 905 data points from over 90 studies (including data from an online BMP database) documenting sediment trapping by vegetated buffers and recorded data regarding buffer characteristics such as buffer width, slope, area, vegetation type, sediment loading, water flow rates, and sediment removal efficiency. We found that an exponential regression model describing the relationship between sediment removal efficiency by the buffer and water inflow/outflow volume ratio explained 44% of the variance. Adding the square root of roughness increased the R ² to 0.50. The model performance was compared with other sediment reduction regression models reported in the literature. The results point towards the importance of considering flow parameters in vegetative buffer design. The improved empirical relationships derived here can be used at local scales to understand sediment trapping potential by vegetated buffers for water quality mitigation purposes and can be built into extant hydrologic models for improved watershed-scale assessments.