Agreement and accuracy of radiographic assessment using a decision aid for medial Oxford partial knee replacement:...

Indication for mobile-bearing partial knee replacement (PKR) is made on the basis of a radiological decision aid. This study aimed to reveal the inter-rater reproducibility and accuracy of the decision aid when used by experienced surgeons.

Anonymised radiographic image sets (anteroposterior, lateral, varus/valgus stress in 20° knee flexion, and skyline views) from 20 consecutive patients who underwent knee replacement were assessed by 12 experienced surgeons. Agreements of each section and accuracy were compared by intra-operative inspection of the status of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and medial and lateral cartilage according to the protocol of Radiographic Assessment for Medial Oxford PKR. Fleiss' kappa (κ) values were used as a statistical measure.

Full-thickness medial cartilage had the best agreement between the surgeons (κ = 94.7%) and best accuracy (94.2%). Although functioning ACL (90.8%), intact cartilage (91.7%) and full-thickness lateral cartilage defects (86.1%) were accurately diagnosed, diagnoses of deficient ACL (up to 42.5%) and partial-thickness lateral cartilage defects (11.7%) were poor; they were sometimes misdiagnosed as being intact. Moreover, agreement of lateral and valgus stress radiographs regarding intact MCL function, as well as the overall decision, was considered to be inadequate (κ = 0.47, 0.58 and 0.51, respectively).

Although the radiological aid is useful for selection of patients who are likely to be suitable for PKR, surgeons should still carefully assess the lateral weight-bearing area for partial-thickness loss and deficiency of the ACL because they were sometimes overlooked by surgeons using radiographs. MRI will be helpful to improve the accuracy of determination of Oxford PKR indication.