Related Experiment Video
Updated: Sep 26, 2025

Improving the Success Rate of Protein Crystallization by Random Microseed Matrix Screening
Published on: August 31, 2013
Environmental Stability of Crystals: A Greedy Screening
Nicholas M Twyman1,2, Aron Walsh1,3, Tonio Buonassisi2,4
1Department of Materials, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom.
Finding materials that are stable in real-world environments is a major challenge in materials science. This study introduces a new algorithm that quickly screens materials for environmental stability. The method uses a greedy approach to estimate the energy needed for a material to break down. When tested on a large dataset of 126,320 crystals, the algorithm had an average error of 39.5 meV/atom, which is accurate enough to identify stable materials. The researchers also tested 39,654 materials in oxygen-rich conditions and found that most oxidation reactions were exothermic, meaning they released energy. Further analysis showed that 1,438 materials could self-passivate based on the Pilling-Bedworth ratio. The algorithm offers a fast and efficient way to screen materials for environmental stability.
Area of Science:
- Materials science and engineering
- Computational chemistry
- Environmental materials research
Background:
Identifying materials that maintain stability in environmental conditions while fulfilling functional requirements remains a challenge. Prior research has shown that thermodynamic stability is a key factor in material performance. However, no prior work had resolved how to efficiently screen large datasets for environmental stability. Existing methods often rely on energy above the hull metrics, which are limited to inert conditions. This gap motivated the development of a new screening algorithm. The approach needed to balance computational efficiency with accuracy. Researchers aimed to expand beyond vacuum conditions to real-world environments. The Pilling-Bedworth ratio is a known criterion for self-passivation. But its application to large-scale datasets had not been fully explored.
Purpose Of The Study:
The goal was to create a rapid screening method for environmental stability in materials. The focus was on thermodynamic stability under common environmental conditions. The study aimed to test the algorithm against existing metrics like the energy above the hull. The researchers wanted to assess accuracy using a large dataset of crystals. They also sought to evaluate performance in oxygen-rich environments. The algorithm was designed to estimate decomposition driving forces. The team aimed to determine if the method could identify stable materials. The study also aimed to explore the potential for self-passivation in 39,654 materials.
Main Methods:
The team developed a greedy algorithm to assess thermodynamic stability. The algorithm was tested using 126,320 crystal structures as input data. The standard energy above the hull metric served as a benchmark. The mean absolute error was calculated to evaluate accuracy. The method was applied to in-oxygen stability for 39,654 materials. The enthalpy of oxidation was computed for each material. The Pilling-Bedworth ratio was used to assess self-passivation. The researchers compared results against known stability criteria.
Main Results:
The greedy algorithm achieved a mean absolute error of 39.5 meV/atom. This level of accuracy is sufficient for identifying stable materials. The method outperformed the energy above the hull metric in computational speed. The algorithm was tested on a dataset of 126,320 crystal structures. In oxygen-rich conditions, the enthalpy of oxidation was largely exothermic. The analysis identified 1438 materials with potential for self-passivation. These materials met the Pilling-Bedworth ratio criteria. The results suggest the algorithm is effective for environmental screening.
Conclusions:
The greedy algorithm provides a rapid and accurate method for environmental stability screening. The approach is suitable for large-scale datasets of crystal structures. The results align with the authors' claim about the algorithm's resolution. The method's performance in oxygen-rich conditions supports its utility. The Pilling-Bedworth ratio analysis highlights potential for self-passivation. The findings suggest the algorithm can identify stable materials efficiently. The study confirms the algorithm's ability to estimate decomposition driving forces. The authors propose the method as a tool for materials discovery.
Frequently Asked Questions
The algorithm estimates the driving force for decomposition with a mean absolute error of 39.5 meV/atom.
The greedy algorithm offers faster computation while maintaining sufficient accuracy for identifying stable materials.
The ratio was used to assess whether materials could self-passivate in oxygen-rich environments.
The algorithm was tested on 126,320 crystal structures and 39,654 materials in oxygen.
It suggests that oxidation reactions release energy, making the process thermodynamically favorable.
The authors propose the algorithm as a tool for rapid environmental stability screening in materials science.
Related Concept Videos
Recrystallization: Solid–Solution Equilibria
Crystal Growth: Principles of Crystallization
Initiating crystallization involves manipulating the concentration of the solute and the temperature of the solution. Since crystal growth occurs when the ratio of concentration and solubility of the solute in the solvent...
Solution Equilibrium and Saturation

