Related Experiment Video
Updated: Sep 22, 2025

Brain State-dependent Brain Stimulation with Real-time Electroencephalography-Triggered Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation
Published on: August 20, 2019
Understanding brain states across spacetime informed by whole-brain modelling.
Jakub Vohryzek1,2,3,4, Joana Cabral1,5, Peter Vuust2
1Centre for Eudaimonia and Human Flourishing, Linacre College, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
This article examines how the human brain maintains a balance between stability and flexibility to function effectively. By using advanced computer models and brain imaging, researchers can map how different brain states, such as those seen in depression or after taking psychedelics, arise from specific patterns of activity. Understanding these patterns may eventually lead to new medical treatments that help restore healthy brain function.
Area of Science:
- Computational neuroscience and whole-brain modelling
- Systems biology and dynamical system theory
Background:
No prior work had fully resolved how the human brain balances stability and flexibility to navigate complex environments. It was already known that neural activity patterns require a delicate equilibrium between order and disorder. That uncertainty drove researchers to investigate how spacetime dynamics underpin various mental states. Prior research has shown that rigid activity patterns often correlate with specific clinical conditions. This gap motivated a deeper look into the mechanisms governing neural transitions. Scientists have long suspected that intrinsic instability is necessary for optimal cognitive adaptability. However, the exact relationship between these emergent phenomena and whole-brain activity remained elusive. This review synthesizes current knowledge to clarify these complex relationships.
Purpose Of The Study:
The aim of this review is to characterize how the human brain maintains flexible behavior through spacetime dynamics. Researchers seek to understand the mechanisms that allow for adaptation to complex environments. The study addresses the problem of how intrinsic and extrinsic signals influence neural stability. It explores the relationship between emergent brain states and the balance of order and disorder. This motivation stems from the need to bridge theoretical neuroscience with clinical observations. The authors intend to clarify how these dynamics change during disease states. They also aim to demonstrate the utility of whole-brain modelling in this context. This work provides a foundation for future research into rebalancing neural activity for therapeutic purposes.
Main Methods:
The review approach focuses on synthesizing recent findings from computational and systems neuroscience. Investigators utilize dynamical system theory to interpret complex neural activity patterns. They examine data derived from neuroimaging studies to calibrate their simulations. The authors evaluate how these mathematical frameworks map onto observed physiological phenomena. This strategy involves comparing healthy brain activity against various altered states. Researchers also assess the limitations of current simulation techniques in capturing temporal shifts. The methodology prioritizes mechanistic explanations over purely descriptive observations. This systematic evaluation provides a comprehensive overview of the field's current trajectory.
Main Results:
The authors report that healthy brain function is defined by a spontaneous equilibrium between order and disorder. Their findings indicate that depression is associated with excessively rigid and highly ordered activity patterns. In contrast, they observe that psychedelic substances induce states characterized by increased disorder and flexibility. The review demonstrates that these distinct states are linked to specific spacetime dynamics. These patterns emerge from the interaction between intrinsic and extrinsic signals within the neural architecture. The researchers show that computational models successfully capture these complex transitions. They highlight that these models provide a quantitative basis for distinguishing between various clinical conditions. The evidence suggests that these dynamics are consistent across different experimental contexts.
Conclusions:
The authors propose that spacetime dynamics serve as a marker for various mental health conditions. Their synthesis suggests that rebalancing these neural patterns could provide a pathway for future therapeutic interventions. The review highlights how dynamical system theory offers a robust framework for interpreting brain activity. They conclude that healthy function relies on a precise equilibrium between rigid order and chaotic flexibility. The researchers argue that altered states, such as depression, exhibit a shift toward excessive stability. Conversely, they note that psychedelic experiences are linked to a move toward increased disorder. This work implies that computational models are vital for mapping these shifts in clinical populations. The authors emphasize that these insights provide a foundation for developing novel strategies to treat neurological disorders.
Frequently Asked Questions
The researchers propose that brain states emerge from a balance between order and disorder. Depression involves excessive rigidity, whereas psychedelics induce increased flexibility, demonstrating how spacetime dynamics dictate the stability of neural activity.
Whole-brain modelling serves as a tool to simulate complex neural patterns. By applying dynamical system theory, scientists can characterize how activity evolves over space and time, providing a quantitative approach to study human cognition.
The authors suggest that intrinsic instability is necessary for optimal adaptability. This state allows the brain to transition between different configurations, which is required for responding to extrinsic signals in a complex environment.
Neuroimaging data provides the empirical foundation for these models. This information allows researchers to map activity patterns across the entire brain, which is then integrated into computational frameworks to test various theoretical hypotheses.
The researchers measure the balance between order and disorder within neural activity. This phenomenon is quantified by observing how spacetime dynamics deviate from a baseline, revealing the degree of flexibility present in a given state.
The authors imply that these findings could inspire new treatments for rebalancing brain states. By understanding the specific dynamics of a disease, clinicians might eventually develop interventions to shift rigid or disordered patterns back toward health.

