Improving team dynamics for project based learning in pharmacy: A multimodal approach

Students taking a research elective with project-based course components have shown aversion to group activities. We aimed to minimize group participation hesitancy and give students autonomy in choice of team formation approach in order to examine the effects of team formation approaches on successful team dynamics.

Learners chose either a student self-selected (SS) or an instructor randomized (IR) team formation approach for two activities (a brief intervention role-play and a review of reviews research symposia presentation). Group development for the different team approaches was studied using the Tuckman model. Using this model, team dynamics was evaluated over five stages of group development: forming, norming, storming, performing, and adjourning. Student reports for each of the phases were evaluated using a project evaluation rubric. For the adjourning phase we used an open-ended survey embedded in the course learning management system. Free text answers from open-ended questions were analyzed for themes related to team dynamics concepts.

Students rated their satisfaction with team performance higher for SS than for IR teams. In terms of individual learning and satisfaction with individual's roles and tasks, they indicated greater satisfaction with the IR approach.

Team formation methods impacted group dynamics and individual attitudes with favorable team dynamics leading to better individual task and overall team performance. Higher team performance corresponds to higher grades for group projects and for courses with group projects, favorable team dynamics could impact students' evaluation of the course.