Identifying Intraoperative Behaviors Associated With Surgical Resident Teachability

The resident-attending dyad influences the intraoperative training of surgery residents. To better understand the role of trainees within the dyad, we hypothesized there is a measurable concept of "teachability," a combination of the trainee's observed skills and behaviors with their performance. This study aims to define teachability and identify discrete intraoperative behaviors that contribute to this concept. We posit that residents who are active learners as demonstrated by asking questions, proposing next steps, and initiating purposeful actions have higher teachability.

Previously recorded videos from 26 laparoscopic inguinal hernia repairs performed by two PGY-5 general surgery residents at a Midwest tertiary care center were qualitatively reviewed for intraoperative behaviors. A summative content analysis identified behaviors associated with increased teachability and improved operative performance assessment scores.

Average frequencies of intraoperative behaviors for resident 1 and 2 (R1 and R2) were not significantly different, although R2 asked more medical knowledge and technical questions. While the rate of attending feedback was similar for both residents (x=3.82 vs 3.40, p=0.646), R1 consistently incorporated feedback (x=2.27 vs 0.40, p=0.001) whereas R2 needed frequent prompting (x=2.45 vs 1.55, p=0.239). R1 scored higher in all but one operative performance assessment category, including overall performance (x=4.17 vs 2.93, p=0.007), but R2 had a larger magnitude of overall improvement (+1 vs +2).

Teachability is a dynamic component of the resident-attending dyad. While intraoperative active learning behaviors do not appear to be associated with teachability, asking questions may increase the magnitude of improvement in performance. Most importantly, the ability to incorporate intraoperative feedback in real time seems to be a critical aspect of teachability and warrants further research.