Biochar alleviating heavy metals phytotoxicity in sludge-amended soil varies with plant adaptability

Recycling sewage sludge (SS) to soil potentially causes soil heavy metal (HM) pollution and plant phytotoxicity. Biochar plays an important role in alleviating HM phytotoxicity, and responses vary with the feedstocks and usage of biochar. However, the effect of plant adaptability on biochar-mediated alleviation is poorly understood. Here, SS-derived biochar (SB) and rice straw-derived biochar (RB) applied at rates of 1.5% and 3% (W/W, SB1.5, SB3, RB1.5, and RB3) were used to improve the properties of soil amended with SS at 50% (W/W). Alleviation of phytotoxicity by biochar was further analyzed with SS-sensitive plant Monstera deliciosa and SS-resistant plant Ruellia simplex. Results revealed that both SB and RB significantly decreased the soil's bulk density and increased water retention. They also changed soil organic matter content and HMs fractionation. The addition of SB or RB alleviated the SS phytotoxicity, and they significantly promoted the growth and the root morphology and physiological index of M. deliciosa. But for R. simplex, these significant changes only synchronously occurred in SB3 treatment. The alleviation in M. deliciosa was more prominent and more closely connected with soil property changes than in R. simplex. Also, more soil property predictors were observed to play an important role in M. deliciosa growth than in R. simplex growth. These results indicated that biochar alleviating HMs phytotoxicity in SS-amended soil is associated with the changes of soil property. Moreover, the alleviation varies more prominently with plant adaptability than with biochar feedstocks and usage.