Density-dependent attributes of schooling in small pelagic fishes

Many small pelagic fishes obligately form schools; some of these schools reach remarkable sizes. Although the school is a fundamental and important ecological unit and is the site of biological interactions such as competition and predation, information on schooling processes in the field remains scarce. Here, we examined the quantitative relationships between population density and school size, the number of schools, and other school characteristics (i.e. packing density, volume, and cross-sectional area) in three species of small pelagic fishes: Japanese anchovy Engraulis japonicus, Japanese sardine Sardinops melanostictus, and chub mackerel Scomber japonicus. We found that school size increased almost linearly with population density, whereas the number of schools and other characteristics increased non-linearly with population density, whereby the rate of increase slowed radically as population density increased. These results indicate that, at low population densities, an increase in density causes an increase in both school size and the number of schools, whereas at higher population densities, an increase in density triggers the formation of larger schools rather than more schools. Furthermore, we found that the shapes of the relationships of all school characteristics with population density differed amongst species. Our results indicate that the schooling behaviour of small pelagic fishes is density-dependent, and responses to changes in density are species-specific. Our results provide insight into how biological interactions such as intra- and inter-specific competition and predator-prey interactions mediate the density-dependent processes that underlie the population dynamics and community structure of small pelagic fishes in marine ecosystems.